I gave an anonymous blowjob during a party dare and I'm pretty sure I know whose dick it was

My best friend Val needed me to come on this overnight lake house trip with our college friend group because her parents only let her go out when I'm there (I'm the alibi, the responsible one, the eternal third wheel lmaoo). The real reason she wanted to go was to spend the night with her boyfriend Cole. I said fine because I love her and also free vacation

So there's about 12 of us at this lake house, drinking, playing cards, eating pizza, and around 10pm someone pulls out a hat and we start doing written dares where you write a dare and how many people have to do it and toss it in

Early dares were chill, sexy dance, call your ex, standard stuff. Then someone pulled out a dare that said "skinny dip for 3 minutes" and the bottle landed on Cole and the girl whose lake house it was

The girl was shy about it but Cole stripped down like it was nothing and when I say I got a FULL view of Val's boyfriend I mean FULL, he was standing there under the patio lights completely naked and I was trying not to stare but also failing because his body was way better than any of us expected, tall and lean but toned, and I noticed very clearly that he was completely shaved down there, like smooth, not a single hair, his cock was right there and the skin around it was bare and I remember thinking "huh, Val's man manscapes, good for her" and then looking away lmaoo

They did their three minutes and got out and we all screamed and laughed and moved on

A few more dares happened and then someone pulled out a piece of paper and read it and the room went dead quiet

"Anonymous blowjob, one girl, one guy, dark room"

Everyone was like WHO WROTE THIS 😭 (still don't know but I have theories lol). After drunk negotiations the rules were: guys each take a separate room, lights off, pillow over face. Girls pick from folded papers and whoever gets the smiley face picks a random room and does whatever she's comfortable with

We picked papers and I unfolded mine and there it was :)

My heart was slamming against my ribs, I was tipsy and my pussy was throbbing just from the adrenaline, I went upstairs and knocked on the first door and opened it and there was a guy on the bed naked with a pillow pressed over his face, I could only see his outline from the garden lights coming through the window

I touched his cock and it was the hardest thing I've ever felt, stiff, thick, smooth skin but rock solid underneath, I wrapped my hand around it and it was bigger than my hand, probably six inches, and when I ran my finger from the tip down to the base he groaned into the pillow and his whole body jerked

I spit on the tip and started stroking him slow and I could hear him gripping the pillow, the fabric crinkling, and I was clenching my thighs together because I was soaking through my underwear just from jerking this guy's cock in the dark lol

I knew time was running out so I leaned down and put the tip in my mouth and swirled my tongue around it and started sucking while stroking the base and his breathing got ragged and his legs were tensing and then without warning he came hard into the back of my throat and I choked and half of it dribbled out onto his thigh because I was NOT ready for the force lmaoo, warm and thick and salty and there was so much 😭

I stroked him a couple more times, wiped my mouth, and left the room on shaking legs

When everyone gathered again it turned into a whole investigation trying to figure out who did what. Nobody suspected me because I'm the innocent responsible one and I kept my face neutral even though I could still taste him

But here's what's been keeping me up at night for weeks

When I was stroking him in that dark room, when I had my hand wrapped around his cock, I ran my fingers around the base and down and there was nothing there. No hair. Completely smooth. Shaved clean.

And the only person I SAW fully naked and shaved that entire night was Cole

Standing under those patio lights two hours earlier

Val's boyfriend

The guy my best friend has been dating for eight months

And I had his cock in my mouth and his cum in my throat and I didn't even know it was him until I was lying in bed that night replaying everything and my brain connected the shaved skin I FELT in the dark to the shaved skin I SAW during the skinny dip and I sat up so fast I almost threw up lol

I keep telling myself lots of guys shave right?? Like maybe half the guys at that party were shaved and I just didn't see them naked?? But I can't get his cock out of my head and I can't look at Val without feeling sick and turned on at the same time and every time Cole texts in the group chat I think about the sound he made when I put my mouth on him

Someone please tell me shaving is extremely common among college guys so I can function normally again, please lol I am begging