I fucked my friend’s sister in college and he still doesn’t know about it

This was probably the most unexpected hookup I ever had in college, it felt like it truly came out of nowhere. I have a friend from high school named Austin. Austin came from a really good family, they were all nice people. We both grew up religious and at the time he was still going to church with his family every Sunday…that’s his mom, dad and his older sister. His sister is Brooke. She was a good, wholesome girl. She’d always done really well in high school and was president of the student council my junior year, when she was a senior. She’s pretty. She’s a brunette of course, with a full body, nice breasts and a great ass. During this time, Austin lived at home still and we went to college together. Our friend group would sometimes go hang out over there on the weekends.

Brooke was away at college in a different city, but would come back to town for big holidays or if it was a long weekend. This time she was back in town for Memorial Day weekend. Brooke and I had spoken a bit before. I wouldn’t say there was necessarily a spark there, but there was a hint of something. I was sure that we both thought the other was attractive. I thought I was reading into it a bit, but in high school when she looked at me it felt like it lingered and she was thinking something that she couldn’t or wouldn’t verbalize. I know she made me horny. I’d pictured what she’d look like on her knees in front of me or what shade of pink her nipples were and how they tasted.

Fantasies aside, we usually just exchanged pleasantries, but I would always joke with Austin and ask if he was ready to have me as a brother-in-law or ask when he was going to set me up with his sister…dumb shit like that. He’d of course tell me to go fuck myself or something to that effect. I never seriously thought of her that way…until that weekend.

It was Saturday afternoon when I went over to Austin’s to pick up something I’d asked him to borrow. To our knowledge the rest of his family was out running errands and it was just him at home. This’ll probably sound insane, but something I did in our friend group as a bit was if I found myself alone in a room, I’d get naked and wait for whoever it was to get back. It’s wild to think back on now, but they’d always be shocked and cuss me out and we’d die laughing after. Austin had gone to get whatever it was he was letting me borrow, so I got naked and waited in his living room. Now I’ve said before, I don’t have the longest cock…it’s a normal length, but girthy in a way that I feel makes it look a lot bigger than it is. When I got naked for my bit, I always would position myself to where my crotch would be facing the exact point of entry in the doorway so whoever it was for sure saw my cock.

I waited for a bit, until I heard someone walking down the hall and I positioned myself perfectly. Imagine my surprise when Brooke was the person that walked in, not Austin. We had no idea she was home. I was obviously mortified right away and covered myself with my hand as she let out the loudest gasp I’ve ever heard. She covered her eyes, apologized and backed out of the room. I thought for sure Austin was going to beat my ass. I got dressed as fast as I could and tried to play it cool. As soon as Austin got back, I made an excuse to bolt out of there. I just knew he was going to text me or call me mad as hell at some point about it, but he never did that day. Or the next day. I never heard from him until Sunday night when he texted the group to invite us all over the next day, because his dad was cooking out for Memorial Day. Everyone agreed so I did as well and hoped I wouldn’t see Brooke.

The next day we all came over for the cookout and were having a good time in Austin’s backyard. I hadn’t seen Brooke yet, so I was hoping she’d gone back out of town. She AGAIN surprised me by walking out…thankfully I wasn’t naked this time. She greeted everyone, but when she saw me we made awkward eye contact and kept our greeting very curt. We hadn’t interacted much the entire time, which was completely fine to me.

I went to use the bathroom and walked out as she was walking by in the hallway, making an awkward traffic situation. We both said excuse me and she looked at the ground. I wanted to apologize, but she started to walk away when I was just about to say something. I said her name and reached out and put my hand on her arm. She looked back at my hand and then up at me when she stopped. I started to apologize and we both started talking at the same time as she was saying it was fine. We both finished talking and then I asked if she told Austin and she said she hadn’t. When I asked her why, she just shrugged. I thanked her for saving me from a potential ass kicking and we both laughed.

After a beat of silence, I apologized in earnest, explaining how it was a stupid bit and we had no idea she was home. She shook her head and agreed about how stupid it was as she laughed. I laughed too as I agreed and told her I’d probably never do it again. She had such a genuine laugh and the way her eyes squinted was really cute and endearing. I don’t know what prompted me to verbalize that, but I did. She blushed and asked if I was hitting on her.

I was a bit on the backfoot there, because the way she asked also sounded flirty. I asked her if it was a bad thing if I was hitting on her and she smiled and asked me if I thought I was being cute. I was going off of the vibe and my instincts at this point, so I told her that I remembered how she looked at me in high school, so she must think I am. I said that I knew she thought about me and that I thought about her. She shook her head in an incredulous way, as if she thought I was being completely ridiculous.

I lifted my hand up to her chin and tilted it up and asked her if she thought I was cute. She raised an eyebrow at me in a sort of, “oh really?” type of way. I inched in slowly to try and kiss her as she met me halfway and gave me just a small peck. She said she’d have to think about it as she put her hand on mine and pulled it off of her chin before walking off. I couldn’t help but check out her ass as she left. She looked back and I boldly kept staring, not changing my reaction as I cycled between looking her in the eyes and then clearly back down at her ass a couple of times before she shook her head, grinning as she walked back outside.

I felt like I could feel my heartbeat in my cock. It was strange because I always knew she was attractive, but now I thought she was sexy. Her attitude, the way she carried herself…in addition to her body. My mind was racing a bit also thinking about her being my friend’s sister, which made me feel guilty. I wrestled with it for a bit before I reminded myself that she’s a grown-ass woman who doesn’t have to answer to anyone and can make her own decisions. I decided I would keep it going to see where this ended up.

Austin’s dad had built two picnic tables that they’d had in their backyard as long as I could remember. I saw there was a spot next to Brooke at one of them as I walked up and I sat by her without saying anything. I saw she was giving me a look again while I took my seat. I joined in the conversation that was going on for a few minutes. I’d seen when I was sitting down that she had her hand closest to me on her thigh. I slipped my hand over to her leg and reached out just my pinky as I hooked it around hers. She gave me a bombastic sideye…but she didn’t move. That made my mind race a bit. Was she kinda into me? Was there actually a vibe there? I unhooked my pinky and moved my whole hand onto her leg, near her knee. She didn’t budge or have any kind of reaction. I pushed a little further. I turned my body slightly towards her as I slid my hand further up her leg on the inside of her thigh.

She still didn’t react, but she brought her hand over and started rubbing the back of my hand lightly in a circle. We stayed like that for a long time as we were all talking at the table. Eventually I lightly squeezed her leg as I let it go, before pulling my hand out from under the table. The way we were oriented, our backs were to their fence, so no one was behind us. I moved my hand around to her back and looped my thumb through the belt loop of her shorts, just above her ass. She shifted in her seat a bit, I’m sure in surprise, but then put her hand on my leg on the inside of my thigh, right where I’d grabbed hers. I couldn’t help it…my cock pulsed.

Her hand was close enough that there was no way that she didn’t notice it. After a moment, she moved and said she would be back in a minute as she gave me a second to get my thumb out of her belt loop. As she got up she whispered, only loud enough for me to hear, to meet her in the guest room at the back of the house in five minutes. I definitely throbbed again in my pants, but tried to play it cool. After about five minutes had passed, I got up with my plate as if I was going to throw it away. I asked if anyone needed anything while I was up and thankfully no one said they did.

I could feel my heart racing on my way to the bedroom. When I opened the door, she was completely naked on the bed with her legs crossed, leaning back and resting her body weight on her arms. I closed the door and was at a loss for words. She got up and walked towards me saying that we were even now since I was seeing her body. I took in the complete sight of her as she drew nearer. Her perfect tits jiggled slightly after each step and her nipples were at full attention, looking me in the eyes and I could just barely see her pussy lips. She didn’t have a full bush, but definitely more hair than I would’ve thought. That didn’t bother me, I never minded a trip into the forest.

I started getting naked as fast as I could and asked if she thought anyone would notice we’d both been gone for a long time. She just said we’d better make it quick as I pulled down my pants. She was standing right in front of me as I’d gotten them off and she slipped her finger into the waistline of my underwear. She told me to take them off as she walked to the bed. She sat down as I got them off and I went over to join her.

We started to lay down together and were kissing before we were all the way horizontal. I grabbed her ass and squeezed as she made a small sound of surprise in her mouth as we kissed. She reached down and put her hand on my cock, it instantly throbbed and started to get hard. She took me in her hand and lightly started tugging on me. I broke our kiss as I leaned my head back making a groan of pleasure. I rolled her onto her back and slid down her body, kissing every inch of skin as I worked towards her center.

She looked down at me as I reached her opening and started exploring it with my tongue. She tensed a bit and I heard a muffled groan as I fused my mouth with her pussy. Her pubic hair rubbed both sides of my face as I ate her out. She writhed as I brought my hand up to enter her slickness as I moved my mouth up to her clit. I circled that bud with my tongue as I entered her with one finger and quickly added another finger to increase the friction in her tunnel.

She bucked a bit, trying not to make any noise as I was fingerfucking her. She squeezed my head with her thighs as she put her hand in my hair, clenching it as I serviced her. She pulled her hands up to her head as she neared her release. I alternated between sucking and licking her clit, while fingering her in a steady rhythm. I felt her go over the edge as her muscles tightened and loosened in random intervals as she shuddered, putting her hands on my head again.

I walked over to my pants in a heap on the floor and found my wallet. I happened to have a condom in there and it definitely came in handy that day. I ripped it open and slid it onto my cock as I turned back and walked towards the bed. She’d laid on her side and was watching me and asked if I really thought we were going all the way. I paused and didn’t know what to say. She smiled and laid on her back and spread her legs. I was nearly in shambles at the cruel joke, but said nothing as I slid onto the bed in front of her.

I gripped my length as I tapped it on her mound. I slid down and spit onto her clit and rubbed my head on it. I slipped in just the tip as our eyes met. I looked down and slid the rest of the way into her. I was transfixed at the sight of my cock sliding in and out of her pussy. I watched as I entered and exited her in a steady cadence, that was not too fast or slow. Not too light or rough. We fucked at a pace that was perfect for this moment. A moment neither of us saw coming, but found ourselves in the middle of now….giving into pent-up carnal desire. She rolled us over and climbed on top of me. She expertly worked her hips, gyrating around in circles side-to-side while sliding up and down my cock at the same time.

I had no idea where this sex goddess came from, but I’m glad she was on top of me now. I reached up and pressed her titties together, kneading them firmly as she rode me. I palmed them and slid my thumbs up to circle her nipples. She put her hands up on her head to give me full access. Then she turned around and rode me, as I entered her from a different angle that curled my toes. Thank god I was wearing a condom or I would’ve already busted before we got to this point. I spit on my thumb and teased the entrance of her ass as she moaned louder.

She reached back for my hands and I linked our fingers, giving her leverage as she leaned back on them while throwing down on me. She sat back up, circling her hips again as I grabbed her ass cheeks and humped into her as hard as I could. I was about to bust hard as hell. I told her I was about to cum as she slowed to an agonizing pace. She looked back and smiled as she leaned forward, taking me in and out of her as she reached her hand back and worked my nutsack. That’s what did me in, I nutted in what felt like seconds after she grabbed my balls. I swear to god I could’ve filled up two condoms. I bucked up until my orgasm slowed while she made a satisfied groan slowly rocking her hips left and right, forward and backward with me still inside of her.

She smirked as she slid off of me, my cock going limp after my release. She quickly got dressed and started to head outside. Before she closed the door behind her, she told me to wait five minutes before coming back out. We fucked the next couple of times that she came back into town for a long weekend. She told me she never told Austin about us and I never have either. I really wanted it to turn into something more than a physical relationship, but I don’t think she ever took it seriously. She ended up dating a guy that she’s still with today. We didn’t part on bad terms and I saw both her and her brother not long ago. They’re doing well and I wish them nothing but the best!