I fucked an emo girl at summer camp, but things got way complicated

As the week went on, Kylie and I kept hanging out, but kept things pretty tame. Just making out and some tame groping. We heard there was a night coming up where everyone in the camp would be gathered in a place on the opposite side of the plaza from where we were staying. I shot Kylie a look and she returned it and I knew that we were going to fuck that night. We went about our duties with our assignments around the camp, I tried to volunteer extra when I could just to help out. One of my shifts was again supervising at the building where me and Kylie had our encounter. This time Lori was there. Lori was the other brunette I met the first day along with Kylie and the blonde girl, Sam. We’d been talking a bit, and we’d worked a couple shifts in the same places, but not necessarily together like we were that day. I was chatting with her, learning about her and her life. She was really interesting and cool. She liked to draw, paint, sew….anything creative. I like doing creative projects too and I always enjoy finding common ground with people so we talked about some different things we’d done.

I have to say here that I think something happens often with me and women that I don’t always intend. I genuinely like to learn more about people and their experiences, because I think it helps me broaden what I think and know. I feel like it comes across as romantic interest because I look people in the eyes when they speak, direct my body language to them and stay engaged, asking them questions to add to what we’ve been talking about. I also try very hard to remember interesting details or something that seems particularly important to people so they feel heard. I think that was the case here because I started to notice as we spoke that Lori was touching her hair and making excuses in the conversation to touch me. She touched my arm a couple of times and at one point playfully pushed me in the chest.

So, I wasn’t sure how to field this situation. Kylie and I never talked about being exclusive, but I felt like it was implied because we planned to hook up. I decided to ask Lori about Kylie and Sam, under the guise of learning how long they’d known each other so I could work Kylie into the conversation naturally. She talked about how the three of them met years ago in middle school, became friends and Sam had suggested they volunteer together this summer. I told her that Kylie and I had been spending time together and that I really liked her. She told me that she knew it’d been steamy, because she and Kylie share everything with each other, as she looked to the vestibule where Kylie had sucked me off. I must’ve blushed or showed some type of reaction because she laughed and said it was ok and she again said they share everything with more emphasis on the word everything this time as she touched my chest. I was reeling in my mind, like holy shit. Both of these girls want to hook up and they both know about it? I could only manage a nod as my brain felt like it was mush at the implication here. She asked for my number and we exchanged contacts. We finished our shift there and I needed to head down to the rec area for my shift there. We exchanged a hug and she smiled saying we’d talk later. When I was about halfway down to the rec area, Lori sent me a text. All it said was to meet later that night with a time and a room number. My cock stirred a little bit just thinking about having carnal activity later. It made me feel a bit lighter that the girls both knew about each other wanting to hook up and were ok with it. I planned on meeting Kylie after my shift, so I went and met her at the plaza after.

We grabbed a bite to eat before taking a walk around the camp, holding hands and talking about anything and everything. We found a more isolated spot and made out for a bit, hot and heavy with our hands roaming all around each other’s bodies. I slipped a hand under her shirt and grabbed her tit, bringing a noise of surprise out of her. I pulled my hand back out and asked if it was too much. She said no and that she was just surprised that I didn’t ask her to see them. I was aghast for a moment as she slipped her shirt off and unclipped her bra, dropping her supple tits out. I was floored at the sight of them. She squeezed them together and asked what I thought. I was at a loss when she said she just wanted to give me a little preview. I kissed her again and started to kiss down her neck to her chest. I started kneading her tits, squeezing them together and letting them fall back into place. You would’ve thought it was the first time I was seeing tits ever, lol. I took one pink nipple in my mouth, rolling my tongue around it as she put her hand on the back of my head. I cupped the other one with my hand and jiggled it left and right lightly. A buried my face between them before switching to suck the other nipple and jiggling the tit I’d been sucking on. I slipped my hand down and slid a couple fingers to the button on her pants and she grabbed my hand making a reprimanding sound, saying that I needed to wait with a playful tone in her voice. I gave her a small smile. She eventually got dressed again as we headed back to the plaza. It was about half an hour before I was to meet Lori when we got back and Kylie had to go for an extra shift she’d volunteered for and told me she’d be going to bed after. We exchanged a hug and agreed to meet at our normal spot in the morning. She told me not to have too much fun without her, with a smirk.

I didn’t quite know what to expect with Lori, but I did a little prep. Cleaning up, grooming, etc. I wore just a thin pair of soccer shorts with no underwear and a plain tee as I got ready to head over. I texted her that I was coming over and she excitedly replied, asking me not to knock so no one would know I was over there. She answered the door in an outfit not too different from mine. Tiny shorts with a plain tank top on, her nipples fully hard already. She asked how it went with Kylie. I told her it was fun and she gave me a playful grin as she slid her hands up and touched her own nipples over her tank top, closing her eyes and leaning her head back. My cock was aching at her touching herself and she eventually pulled off her tank top. Her tits were small, but cute. I didn’t mind as long as I could get them in my mouth. She closed the space between us, kissing me hard as she ran her fingers through my hair as we both laid on the bed. I met her with the same energy as things started to get hot and heavy. I broke from our kiss to slide down and kiss her neck. I grabbed one tit and as I moved down brought my free hand up to grab the other as I started licking, alternating between the two. She let out a groan as she grabbed my head.

I moved to her nipples, running my thumb over a small beauty mark, just to the left of one. Her small, perky tits fit perfectly in my hands as I started to suck on her nipples. As I was sucking on them she reached down and grabbed my cock, slowly pumping me. I let out a groan and she told me to lay back. She slipped off my shorts, before slipping off hers which raised my eyebrows a bit. She smiled and slid down to lick my tip while she grabbed me at the base. I tensed a bit as I was shocked at the escalation from talking to her earlier, to her now sucking my dick, but she told me to relax. I eased up and she started to bob up and down, getting me fully hard in no time. Her oral skills were 10/10. Slobbering like crazy, working my balls, tongue in the ass….the works. She started sucking me to the point of hollowing her cheeks and sliding up to make a popping sound as she took me back in, to the hilt so she could repeat the move. This had my toes curling and hips bucking before she let up saying not to cum before we could really play.

I swapped places with her to eat her pussy. I tongued at her entrance as I slipped a finger in at the same time, working both in tandem. She let out a moan louder than intended before covering her mouth with one hand and grabbing my hair with the other. I pushed her legs up and told her to grab her knees. When she did I slid up to circle my tongue around that all-sensitive bundle of nerves. She bit her lip to keep from moaning out again as I started to pump two fingers into her with one hand while licking her clit. I wet the middle finger of my other hand in her opening, before sliding that down to tease her asshole. I continued this three-pronged attack until I felt the coil of muscles in her core start to spring free as they started contracting. She bucked her hips up into my mouth, nearly pulling my hair out in the process. I didn’t mind. This was the sexy kind of pain, the type of pain you know will be followed by a huge wave of pleasure, making it all the sweeter when you finally hit your release. Her trembling subsided and she rubbed her nipples, smiling down at me, putting one hand on her head and the other in my hair.

She apologized for pulling my hair and I smiled, telling her I liked it. I told her it made me hard as a motherfucker to watch her cum and I gripped my cock as I sat up near her entrance. She gasped a bit as I started to slap her mound with my length and then rubbing her clit with my frenulum, spitting down onto that bud to speed up the motion until she writhed in pleasure again. She begged me to fuck her. I slipped in just the tip as I looked in her eyes, seeing them plead for more. I slowly slid in and pulled back out to circle her clit with my head again. I kept this pace up, sticking it all the way in her pussy and pulling out to rub that bud over and over. Eventually she rolled us over and sat up to ride me. She crouched over my cock looking at me as she sat on it, taking me in to the point that I disappeared inside of her. She circled her hips like mad as she rode, throwing her pussy down like she was a porn star. She felt unreal, just tight enough to cause that friction I needed to inch towards my release. I sat up and rolled her into the bed, face down. I swung my legs over her thighs and started drilling down into her pussy from behind.

This prone bone was sexy as hell, with her plump asscheeks jiggling with every hump. I slid in to the hilt and stayed buried in her as I circled around and slapped her ass. I spread her cheeks as I pulled out of her and poked at the entrance of her ass, spitting down to increase the moisture. I asked her if she wanted it in her ass and she moaned that she did. I told her to beg for it as she moaned for it louder. I slowly slipped my head into the tight orifice. She reached back and spread her cheeks to give me more space as I took full advantage and slipped halfway in. The grip hurt in the best way, as her walls squeezed my cock. As I picked up speed I spit down again for more moisture as she started groaning for me to fuck her harder. A reached down and pinned both her arms behind her back as I humped like a madman. I felt my orgasm coming, groaning out that I was about to cum. She told me not to stop as my orgasm hit. I busted deep inside of her ass, that intense grip milking out every drop. I slid out of her after a few last pumps and collapsed on the bed next to her. As we laid there catching our breath I reached over and grabbed her ass as I saw my spend start to dribble out of her tight pucker…this was some of the hottest shit I’d ever seen. I didn’t really stick around for much pillow talk since it was getting late, which made me feel a bit like this was a toot it and boot it situation, lol. I slipped out back to my room for the night.

In the morning I met Kylie at our normal spot to head down for our shifts. She asked how the rest of my night went and I told her it was awesome with a playful grin, eyebrows up. She smiled back and let out a sexy giggle, saying she was happy to hear it. She leaned in to whisper that tonight would be a lot of fun too. The thought of going back-to-back with these sexy brunettes definitely made my dick twitch, and I told her I was excited. We went through our normal shifts until we met everyone back up at the plaza for lunch. Kylie was sitting next me and Zack was on my other side. As we’re talking in our group having a normal conversation, I see Kylie’s hand sneaking over and rubbing my crotch and grabbing my semi through my shorts. I had to have been blushing tomato red. This was pretty wild, to be sitting here talking with a whole group while she grips and starts pumping my length. I caught Lori’s eye and she gave me a grin as if she knew what was going on. When we got up from the table, I obviously had to hang out for a second before I left, lol. Kylie got up and took a few steps before asking if I was “coming,” pun definitely intended. After I got my semi under control, I followed her back to our dorms to get ready for the meeting we were secretly skipping. She texted me and said she’d come to my room in about 10 minutes when everyone would start to leave to head to the meeting. In the time I had, I again did some prep work, just like with Lori. Washing up, grooming and all that good stuff. She texted me as she was walking up and I opened the door for her to slip in.

We both laughed and started kissing immediately. God she was sexy as hell. I picked her up by her ass and carried her over to the bed as she let out a small sound of surprise before wrapping her legs around me. I laid her down and climbed on top of her, sliding my hand up her shirt to cup her tits. She didn’t have a bra on which made me harden in my shorts. She said she wanted to make things easy. I slipped off my thin shorts I was wearing with no underwear to let my cock spring out and told her I wanted to make it easy too. We both got naked in the bed as fast as we could. Neither of us could wait to touch the other as we wrapped our bodies up, entwined like vines. She reached down and grabbed my cock and softly started stroking it. I, in turn, reached down to touch her entrance. We both groaned as we serviced each other.

I’d spit on my fingers to get some moisture down there, only to find she was getting wet already. I told her I could see she was already excited and she smiled, a slight blush coloring her cheeks. I slipped one finger in before she had a moment to react and she let out a gasp. I smiled and kissed her throat as she leaned her head back. She pulled my hand that’d just been inside of her up to her mouth and sucked my fingers, cleaning off all her moisture. She then took my hand and put it on her throat and closed it lightly. I slid down taking her nipples in my mouth, circling around them while lightly squeezing her throat. I went back up to kiss her as she pushed me to roll us over and got on top of me. She squeezed her tits together and leaned down, letting go and rubbing them in my face as she giggled. I took full advantage and gave her a classic motorboat, making us both laugh.

She sat up and said she needed me inside of her…that she’d been thinking about it all day. She spit in her hand and reached down to pump me a bit before guiding me to her entrance. This pussy felt divine. I thought about Lori and how we’d fucked raw, but she said they share everything so it was only a fleeting thought. She started to ride me, putting her hands up in her hair as she alternated between taking me in, grinding back and forth and also throwing her pussy up and down in a steady rhythm. This girl knew how to ride. I looked up as her tits bounced and I bent my knees a bit to where her hamstrings were on my thighs. I started bucking up as she slammed down, our thrusts starting to match pace. I started humping like mad as she stopped and let me find a rhythm of driving my cock up into her as she worked her nipples.

I eventually slowed down and she took control again, taking me in fully while grinding her hips around while I was inside of her. As she started bouncing again I slipped out of her. She pumped me a few times before turning her back to me and sitting on my cock, riding me again. She leaned all the way forward, face down, as she threw her hips up and down. This angle was insane. I was hitting her walls in all the right spots. I grabbed her ass as she moved up and down, squeezing and slapping her cheeks while she moaned. When I circled her asshole with my thumb she looked back and gave me a clear head shake to say no, so I eased off. This pussy was more than enough for me. She got back to her cadence on my cock as I groaned at the friction. I wasn’t close quite yet, but I asked her where she wanted me to cum. She just looked back with a smirk and opened her mouth wide. I took control and put her on her side with one leg pulled up as I penetrated her from an angle that she clearly wasn’t used to.

She moaned out cussing as she held her leg up to give me space to work. I humped like mad in that position and felt that tickle nearing and told her I was about to cum. She laid down flat, face up and told me to fuck her mouth. I slid up and leaned over, my body parallel to hers and my release hit just as I entered her mouth. I put both elbows on the bed to brace myself as I buried myself into the back of her mouth, down to my base. My pulsations were intense, filling her up with my cum as I moved. She started to choke a bit, making the most lewd sounds and gagging as she took my seed down her throat. She leaned up and showed me my spend before swallowing it and sticking out her empty tongue, smiling. I panted there for a bit until I flipped around and sat her on my face, determined to help her find her release too. I put my whole mouth on her entrance, tonguing it while moving a finger inside her like I did with Lori. It elicited the same reaction from Kylie as she let out an undignified groan. I added a finger, hooking it inside of her creating friction on her walls as I licked around her clit, circling it and lightly sucking on it.

Before too long she grabbed my hair, bearing down on me through her release, her walls gripping my fingers with intense pulsations before she slid off and laid in bed next to me. We both laid there completely spent as we caught our breath. I snuggled up behind her to spoon while we randomly let out curses and deep breaths. We laid there now just kissing lightly, tenderly. I pretended to give her a hard time about telling Lori about the blowjob and she blushed a bit, saying Lori’s same line about sharing everything. We laughed a bit, before I told her it was funny that she said the same thing, which made me think for a second. I told her it was kind of funny too that the same finger and mouth combo made Lori cum too. She stopped smiling and sat up and asked what I was talking about. I told her Lori said they share “everything,” and she knew about the blowjob and texted me her room number and a time.

Kylie looked incredulous. She seemed to have a hard time finding her words. She asked when this was and I told her it was yesterday, asking if Lori had not talked to her about it after all. She said she’d not heard a word about it. She’d told Lori about the blowjob…how hot it was. She apparently explained it in detail and it definitely piqued Lori’s interest, but they’d said nothing about this kind of arrangement. I was caught in the middle and felt like much of the fault was on me for not clarifying or communicating properly. I must have misread signs and misunderstood some conversations. I apologized and she just shook her head. She demanded to know what we did. I wasn’t sure what to do in that moment, but ultimately I knew I needed to be honest and I told her about our encounter. She rubbed her temples with her finger tips and asked if we used a condom. I told her we didn’t and she followed up asking if I came inside of her. I told her that I had. She wrapped her arms around herself, clearly upset. She muttered to herself, picking her clothes up and getting dressed. I tried to comfort her and she said she felt so stupid and that she wanted to leave. I relented and after she got dressed I went to hug her before she left. She rebuffed my touch and said she needed time alone. I didn’t know where to go from there. I felt terrible about the whole thing, feeling more and more at fault, but I also didn’t know if Lori was partly to blame too? I texted Lori telling her we needed to talk. I heard nothing back. I texted Kylie to check on her and never heard back from her either. Eventually it got late and I decided to go to bed and try to resolve it in the morning.

After I woke up I checked my phone and had still not heard back from either one of them. I went to our usual meeting spot in the morning, but Kylie never showed up. I talked to Zack and asked if he knew anything. He told me that he saw Kylie earlier and that she left early that morning saying something came up at home. I asked if he’d seen or heard from Lori and he’d not. I was crashing out…I had no idea what was happening. Eventually, I saw Sam and asked her if she’d spoken to either of them. She looked at me disgusted and asked if I was going to try and sleep with her too. I felt terrible. She eventually told me that Lori had left the camp in tears that morning too, after telling Sam her account of what’d happened.

I’ve still not spoken to either of them since this happened, though I’ve tried to reach out. I did hear that they were no longer friends, which I can’t help but feel responsible for. I have mixed emotions, which also makes me feel a bit guilty. This is such a sexy memory, I think about fucking both of them sometimes, but the situation makes me feel regretful. In the end, I had no choice but to move on and accept that I’ll likely never get closure on this. I’m sorry this didn’t have a happy ending, but I can’t change what happened and I just write it as I lived it.