As I mentioned in my previous post, my buddy Tim and his wife wanted to dip their toes into the world of wife swapping with me and my wife. This resulted in an amazing evening where I went over to their house and spent some time welcoming Natalie into this world while our spouses went out to dinner. While Tim was ok with me and his wife being together, Natalie knew herself and her insecurities and knew it would take some time for her to warm up to the idea of sharing Tim with my wife. Totally understandable and we weren't pushing them in that direction, especially since my wife seems more turned on by the idea of sharing me than playing with others herself.
A few weeks went by since that first encounter. We had all hung out a few times since then and everything was normal between the four of us, as it always had been. But there had also been some planned encounters just with me and Natalie. To say that we were sexually compatible was an understatement. Obviously, no one rivals my wife, but the way Natalie and I were able to explore and please each other was incredible. Each encounter was better than the last.
One evening they had come over to our place to hang out. We ordered pizza and spent time catching up and having fun. After dinner I got up to make coffee for everyone. I came back to the living room and sat down next to Natalie, who instinctively cuddled up next to me.
It's kind of strange. Her and I had done basically everything together. Been intimate in every way. But we'd never so much as kissed or cuddled in front of our spouses. My wife, always keen to break the ice, giggled, saying, "Sheesh, get a room you two!"
All four of us laughed at that. It wasn't as if Natalie and I were suddenly about to go upstairs and bang it out (even if the thought immediately crossed my mind). Natalie shot back, "I mean, we would, but then you two would be bored all alone."
"Oh I'm sure they can find something to do," I said with an obnoxious grin.
"And what might that be?" Natalie responded.
"Depends what you're ok with."
The elephant in the room was that any action between my wife and Tim was contingent on Natalie's comfort with the idea. I hadn't broached the subject with her, but I could now tell it was on her mind.
With a pensive look on her face, she slowly said, "Ok, I've been thinking about it. I think I'm starting to be ok with that. But I'd want to be in the room when it happens."
The room was silent. "Are you sure?" my wife asked.
"Yeah, I think so." Natalie responded, sounding more confident.
Tim, being a guy, couldn't help but suddenly have an obnoxious smile on his face. Out of the four of us, he's the most quiet and introverted. Sometimes it's hard to read his emotions. That was not the case right now. He looked over at his wife, who smiled at him, then looked at my wife with a knowing look in his eyes.
"Ok how about this," I interrupted. You two go home. Talk about it. If you're ok with it, text us and we'll come over in an hour or so.
They lived down the street from us, so we often went back and forth between our houses when we hung out. Plus I figured this would give everyone some time to get ready a bit if something were to happen.
As soon as they left and the door closed, my wife turned to me with a huge smile. "You ready for this?" I asked.
"You know I am. I just hope Natalie is ok with it."
Thirty minutes later in our group chat, Natalie texted, "Soooooo, you guys coming over or what?" We were in the car within 30 seconds of that text and at their door 2 minutes later.
Tim and Natalie opened the door together. "Hey long time no see!" I said, always keen to lighten the mood with lame jokes. I wasn't sure how this would proceed, and was slightly worried about awkwardness derailing all of it. That fear was short lived. After I stepped inside, Natalie hugged me in welcome, but then wouldn't let go as she normally would. Instead she leaned in and kissed me. Passionately. I guess I didn't have to worry about awkwardness.
She led me by the hand into their living room, right off the entry foyer. I glanced behind me and saw my wife and Tim in a similar embrace, but not kissing. I sat on the couch and Natalie immediately straddled me. She was wearing a light blue sundress that showed off her legs perfectly. I let my fingers trace up and down her calves as she leaned in and kissed me again.
On the other couch I saw my wife and Tim in a similar position. She looked back at us and took that as her cue to kiss Tim for the first time. I couldn't take my eyes off them, as I watched Tim hesitantly wrap his arms around her and feel up and down her back, resting on her round ass. I broke my kiss with Natalie and whispered in her ear, "You're ok with this? Or do you need a bit more distraction?"
She grinned and pushed her hips forward, so she was almost sitting on my very hard dick. "I'm always happy to be distracted by you."
I caressed her calves and thighs, and then let my hands roam under the hem of her dress, which ended around mid-thigh. I reached up and quickly realized she wasn't wearing panties. I let one hand slip between her legs and could immediately feel how wet she was. I traced up and down her pussy lips with my middle finger, eliciting a slow, "Ohhhhhhhh fuuuuuuuck" from her lips.
That got the attention of our spouses. Who both looked over to us and could see what I was doing to her. My wife was still straddling him, but was clearly grinding her pussy against his cock. I figured they were taking their cues from us. I fingered Natalie for a few more seconds before whispering "Turn around. I need to fuck you now."
Without responding she stood up as I pulled my pants down to my ankles. Tim and my wife were glued to the scene across the room. Natalie grabbed my fully hard dick and stroked me a few times, and finally gave me one slow, long lick around my head. She then turned around to face away from me, held my dick in her hand, and lowered herself onto me.
She was still wearing her dress, so they couldn't see me enter her, but there was no doubt what was happening. She began to rock back and forth in my lap as she pressed her back against my chest and I reached around to massage her tits.
After watching us for a moment, our spouses quickly began to strip their clothes off. My wife was wearing a sexy set of lacy panties and a bra, but poor Tim barely got to see them before they were on the ground. She got on her hands and knees on the couch and he got behind her. No foreplay. I could tell they'd both been looking forward to this for weeks.
From my angle I couldn't see everything. But I could see that he rubbed his dick up and down her pussy lips a bit before pushing forward and into her. A light moan escaped her lips as he entered her for the first time.
Since Natalie was facing away from me, she was watching all of this unfold. I half expected her to feel a pang of jealousy and stop it, but she continued to ride my dick, moaning to herself as she watched. My wife and Tim picked up the pace. Soon he was pounding her hard and her moans were filling the room.
"I'm not going to last long," he moaned out.
"In me. Give it to me. I want it in me." my wife replied, breathless.
He grabbed her hips and pushed forward, unloading in my wife's tight pussy. She later told me she had a mini-orgasm as he came. Entranced, Natalie and I had mostly stopped moving while watching the scene in front of us. As our spouses came down from their high and ended up cuddled on the couch, I reached around and started to rub Natalie's clit while I was still inside of her. She began to ride me again, closing her eyes and grabbing her tits as I caressed her clit.
"Did you like watching your husband cum in my wife?" I whispered, quiet enough just for her to hear.
"Uh huuuuh," she replied, moaning.
After watching my wife get taken care of like that, I was more turned on than I'd ever been. I wasn't going to last long and I told her so.
"Cum in me. Please. I need it." she begged.
I rubbed her clit furiously. I felt her body begin to tense up as an orgasm overtook her. Her pussy spasmed and contracted, tightening around my cock and spurring my own orgasm. We both stopped moving as I unloaded everything I had in her. Our spouses were watching us and I suddenly made eye contact with my wife as I came in her best friend's pussy.
The room was silent for a few minutes. My cock softened inside of Natalie and eventually slipped out of her.
As always, my wife was keen to lighten the mood. "You know, the four of us should hang out more often" she joked. All four of us laughed at that.
Needless to say, our get togethers were often quite different after that evening.