This story took place a few years ago during the early years of college.
To give some backstory, my parents were family friends with another couple (our parents had known each other for years) who had a daughter named Ella that was the same age as me. Ella and her family had re-moved to our hometown towards the end of high school.
Ella was immediately labelled as the absolute sweetest, nicest, and intelligent girl at our school. To give an idea of what she was like, she had long curly brown hair, always wore these harry potter style glasses, and spent almost all her free time at school either reading or drawing. She was also extremely friendly, was almost always smiling, and just had this way of talking where she got along with just about everyone.
So fast forwarding to college. Ella and I went to different school but still kept in touch. We would only text on occasion - mostly when the other needed help with something - for me it was always help with something school related as she was the 'smart' one, and for her it was gym or work out advice because I was the 'athletic' one. So to give a picture of myself - I'm a pretty good looking guy, fairly tall (6’2) and built more on the athletic side than body-builder type. Basically I have a soccer player build and have always focused on squats, running, and ab work - that kinda thing.
Anytime myself and Ella were home from school our families would usually link up and have a dinner or something together.. thanksgiving, winter break, spring break.. you get the point.. Even after a few years of college Ella was still the same sweet, friendly, and cute Ella that she had always been. Like I have said, she was incredibly cute and up to this point I don't think I had ever heard her talk about anything sex related or even be in a sex related conversation. Because of all that, she was never someone that I had ever tried to flirt with... she was just.. cute Ella. And that isn't to say she wasn't attractive - because she was - it was just more that she was this innocent and sweet friend of mine. That's the only way I know how to describe it..
Anyways.. during one of the breaks that we were both home from college, I had invited her and one of her friends over to our house to watch a movie and chill with me and one of my friends. It was mostly just a way to catch up with each other and talk about how school was going. Well, for some reason the friend that I had over kept making jokes about how I have a small cock. I don't know why some guys do this. But he dropped maybe three lines back to back like, "that's because you have a small dick.." Never really understood why some guys make this joke.. anyways.. I was getting annoyed by it and the girls weren't really laughing at the jokes.. so it was generally just a little awkward. Ella was also family friend so it was just uncomfortable.. Eventually he makes the SAME joke a fourth time and under my breath I kinda just mumble, "nah 6 point 5 inches.. not that small." I thought I had whispered it under my breath enough that no one heard it, but looking back I think I did see Ella kinda grin/chuckle after my response... but she was always smiling... the conversation (and the night) quickly moved on and was over.. and I didn't think much about it.
Flash to the next time we are home. Ella had asked me to go for a slow run/jog with her, mainly to catch up. We chatted as usual about school/job prospects for summer.. that kinda thing. But towards the end of the run Ella had asked me how much longer the run would take. I looked down at my watch and replied, "hmm i don't know about six.. five minutes-ish.." Right away she starts to giggle (confusing me) and replies to my confusion with, "six point five." I was still confused which she could see. So she blurts out, "inches... six point five.. inches" and starts to laugh. Immediately I kinda turned into a ghost and started to apologize with, "oh god... you heard that.. ahhh.. sorry..." Ella kinda just laughed it off (it really did come off just as her being goofy) and she started the conversation back to school. That had honestly been the first time that I had ever heard her say or mention anything even adjacent to something you could categorize as dirty.
So we go back to school. When randomly late one Saturday night I get a text string from Ella that says:
Ella: 6.5
Ella: hahahah
Ella: that always makes me laugh.. jimmy is such a jerk
So this was really out of left field. I was thinking of replying with something flirty but because it was Ella I still replied with something like, "haha yeah he is.. can't believe you heard me say that... ahh.. sorry" To which she replied with an, "haha all good just makes me laugh" then she completely changed the subject to school. So even after that text thread, my vision of Ella as the sweet innocent one was still very much intact - I figured she was just being goofy (it was still only the second sex related comment I think I had ever heard her say.. so again I kinda just brushed it off and forgot about it)..
Now to the day where my perception of innocent Ella completely disappeared. Moving forward again to when we are home for summer break. Ella and I's parents were going to a concert together so our family went over to theirs for an early dinner. After dinner, our parents left together and Ella and I were tasked with having to drive and pick them up after the concert as they were going out for some drinks beforehand.. To kill some time we played some board game (that she destroyed me at) then we went to her basement and decided to throw on a movie. I sit down on the couch, and as she is setting up the tv and gets the movie going and fiddling with the stereo, she grabs a ruler that was sitting on the top of the tv stand (looking back I think she may have planted that ruler) grabs it, turns around, moves her hands to pinch the length she wants, laughs and says, "look 6.5 inches". I am kinda stunned but I just shake my head and awkwardly laugh. She then starts using it as a wand and pretending to cast a spell (which was the same goofy nerdy Ella I know) and throws it on the couch sitting next to it.
About 20 minutes into the movie, Ella runs up and decides to make some popcorn and I pause the movie. As she comes down with the bowl, she puts it between us, looks me in the eyes, and says point blank, "Okay be honest. Is your dick actually 6.5 inches.. do you like really know the exact measurement"
At this point I am expecting the same goofy and innocent Ella to chime in and start to giggle but she just stares directly at me waiting for a response. Right away it felt like the sweet innocent Ella persona she had was almost taken over by a new flirty (and kinda slutty) Ella persona..
Stunned, I reply with, "umm yeah maybe a little bit bigger.."
"So like have you measured it before?"
As every guy can probably attest, I replied honestly with, "yeah.. I have." At this point I was still in shock that Ella of all people was saying this. Like she was letting out a side of herself she had always wanted to..
She then adds, "Really? And it was 6.5? Like.. Hard?"
I reply, "Yeah hahah.. hard"
The innocent and sweet Ella was gone in my eyes now too. Now looking at her, everything just felt incredibly sexy. Her glasses. Her hair. Her laugh. She was just straight up fuckable.
With the ruler in her hand, she then asks, "Can I measure it?"
Before I know it, she had quickly unzipped my pants and pulled them off. She then looked up at me, smiled, and pulled off my boxers revealing my semi-hard cock. It had all happened so quickly that I wasn't even fully hard yet, but before I know it she had grabbed the ruler with one hand and my cock with the other.
She reached her hand around my cock and started to slowly stroke it to make it fully hard. It did not take long. She then pushed the ruler against it and whispered out, "like 6.4.. umm 6.5.. maybe like 6.6.."
"I think it's closer to maybe like 6.6 inches!" she said kinda giggling.
Then, she stands up and says, "I'll be right back. Stay put." Before I know it, she is back in the basement with a condom in her and now fully naked. Turns out Ella had an incredible body hiding underneath.
Point blank, she looks at me and says, "Can we fuck?"
Easy answer for me, "Yeah"
"Can I suck your cock first?"
Easier answer, "Yes."
She starts to suck my cock, and seeing the look in her face, it was like she had been dreaming about it everyday for months. Innocent Ella was gone and slutty Ella had been unleashed. Eventually I chime in with, "Yeah we should fuck."
I throw on the condom, and she jumps on the couch on top of me and starts to fuck me screaming and moaning louder than I ever thought possible. Eventually I tell her that I am getting close to cumming which immediately makes her cum and somehow scream even louder. I could still feel her jolting as I ripped off the condom and came all over her tits and body.
After we did some cleanup, and some awkward chit chat, we went and picked up our parents from the concert together.
Once they stepped in the car it was like she had flicked a switch back to her cute old self but I could never see her as the sweet innocent one again.
​